You Can't Put the Genie Back in the Bottle
American Pravda (AKA NY Times) reports today that the annual conference of the Catholic Bishops of the United States is taking up the subject of artificial intelligence (AI) at the urging of Pope Leo XIV. In another article, the Times reports that the Anti AI movement is growing on college campuses and various school boards have objected to using Google if it uses AI. Everyone, including the stock market, is in a state of panic. Numerous political luminaries of both parties have expressed concern about AI as well. Does anyone know what they are talking about? All we hear is how people are going to be hurt by this new modality. Is it true? What's going on?
I don't pretend to be an expert on AI. In fact I know very little about it. What I do know is that progress cannot be stopped. Just think of the Atomic Bomb. The US won the race to develop that weapon and used it twice to end World War II in the Pacific. Efforts were made to prevent the spread of this weapon, but by 1948 the USSR, in an effort directed by secret police chief Lavrenty Beria, tested their own A bomb. The US went on to develop the Hydrogen bomb and the Soviet Union followed afterward. Diplomatic efforts to stop the spread of nuclear weapons failed. The United KIngdom followed with an A-bomb and other countries followed. Much of the tension in international relations today is centered on Iran's striving to develop an A-bomb and American efforts to stop it. A more relevant example would be the automobile, also known as the horseless carriage. As automobiles became common in the early twentieth century, many occupations associated with horses became extinct, as partisans screamed at motorists "get a horse". Has anyone used the word "farrier" in the last seventy-five years? Does anyone know what it means? one who shoes horses. How many farriers were displaced due to the horseless carriage? Electric lights caused lamplighters to become redundant. Is anyone prepared to give up electricity? French workers threw shoes into machines to stop progress. Thus the word "saboteur" from the French word "sabot" or work shoe. One can only conclude that progress cannot be stopped!
Can laws be passed which will regulate AI? Remember laws which were passed to contol alcoholism and promote temperance, namely prohibition. A constitutiutional amendment was even passed. The result was widespread ignoring of this "noble experiment" as the American public did as it pleased. The same with attempts to control reproductive freedom with laws and judicial decisions rendering abortion illegal. Laws which make honest people into criminals ab initio are valueless and invalid. The same will happen with laws to regulate AI. Even if legitimate scientific research can be controlled in the US, it cannot be controlled internationallly. Thousands of foreign students are studying in American undergraduate and graduate schools, including many from China and Iran, who will return to their home countries and continue their scientific work. If the remainder of the advanced world progresses in AI while the US freezes or controls AI research, we will fall behind as progress passes us by.
What should America do? Instead of worrying about AI, we should worry about RD or real dumbness. Regrettably American primary and secondary school education leaves a lot to be desired as American students rank poorly in math and science in comparison to students in many other countries. Reading and math scores are abysmal and many colleges and universities no longer properly grade their students and the students don't get their money's worth for their expensive higher education. So, let's work on improving American schools at all levels. Let high school and college graduates get a proper education so that they can properly compete in the newly challenging world that they will live in. America has led the world for the past century. There is no reason to cede our position to other countries. Yes, Amercan students willl have to work hard, but nobody ever said life was easy. It's time for America to get down to business and achieve what it is capable of. There is no alternative to the sun rising tomorrow morning. There is no escape from reality. AI is here to stay and will grow. There must be no fear of progress as it cannot be stopped. We must accept reality and its challenges. There is no alternative. Falling behind and failing are not options. There is ony one direction-forward into tomorrow and all it offers. We can do it!
Garry S. Sklar
Las Vegas, NV
November 18, 2026
Comments